Hi guys I just finished reading Eragon, Eldest, and Brisngr and thought they were pretty good. One of the biggest problems with them I thought was that he didn't give Murtah and Thorn enough page time. But he did a really good job bringing the characters to live. The Eragon movie however I thought was terrible. It was almost nothing like the book, only the main plot was the same. Every detail was completely off. All in all i would give the books a 8-10 and the movie 2-10. If any one has any questions or comments about the movie or the books just post them.